Europe is far from the Far West, but according to ESSEC Professor Viviane de Beaufort, Director of the European Center for Law and Economics (CEDE), shots have started flying! Point of view by Viviane de Beaufort in collaboration with Caroline Riesco and Mahamadou Niakate.
Qualifying shareholder activism — when investors attempt to use their rights as shareholders of a publicly-traded corporation to bring about change — requires careful nuance. Jean-Pierre Jouyet, president of the ‘Autorité des Marchés Financiers’, once declared in 2010 that “France is still the Far West of corporate takeovers”. In other words, he argued that takeovers involving French firms often involve a fight.
Institutional investor activism: “the good”
Institutional investors favor negotiation rather than aggressive activism. In other words, they tend to work directly with off-line executives and management to make their voices heard. Institutional investors like Vanguard and Blackrock, for example, promote engagement through in-house discussions with management, which helps them avoid issuing public directives to management. However, they are more likely to threaten divestment. The Norwegian sovereign fund, for example, has divested from several firms in which they had lost confidence. Institutional investors also rely on voting advisors (proxies) for advice and clarification on important issues. In this regard, the CDC (Caisse des Depots) is a major player in France, which has established its voting policy with a governance committee, uses services like Proxinvest and ISS, and organizes negotiations before the AGM.
Hedge fund activism: “the bad”?
Hedge funds seek to achieve a significant change in the strategy of the company, and can use force to achieve this change. Pershing Square Capital put pressure on the Canadian Pacific Railway in 2012, for example, to elect its list of candidates to its board. Consequently, studies have shown that companies targeted by activist hedge funds have a lower perpetuity rate than the average: 63% after four years compared to 84%. Hedge funds are furthermore criticized for not paying much attention to operational activity, and intervening through financial maneuvers, which tend to weaken the company if it finds itself in a difficult economic situation.
For example, in August 2013, the British hedge fund activist The Children’s Investment Fund (TCI), which said that it held more than 1% of EADS’ capital, wrote to Executive Chairman Tom Enders asking him to step down as soon as possible. Participation in Dassault Aviation: “You have insisted that EADS is now a” normal “company, seeking the profits and interest of private shareholders.” However, other authors such as Fabrice Rémon argue that this type of activism is good because it shakes-up the business.
Are other forms of minority shareholder activism therefore “the ugly”?
Very different types of investors concern us here: individual shareholders; Holders of non-controlling minority interests such as asset managers and pension funds; Non-governmental organizations; trade unions and actors in the voluntary sector; Voting counseling agencies also have a special role in France. The common point of these shareholders is their position as minority or external shareholder and the methods they can use to gain influence. But they have very diverse objectives: the individual shareholder will often be most interested in the long-term prosperity of a company rather than its short-term. For example, an individual shareholder voiced his concern at the 2014 Air Liquide AG, asking whether it would be wise to pay the dividend in cash when the Group had to finance the acquisition of Airgas. Sometimes, individual investors act in the name of the greater good. NGOs are also starting to intervene. In particular, Friends of the Earth, which is particularly vigilant about climate change commitments, at the AXA AGM asked “what is the threshold for dis-investing companies most involved in climate change activities related to coal?”
With kind acknowledgements to ESSEC Knowledge
- Learn more about Prof. Viviane de Beaufort and her work
- Read more of Viviane de Beaufort’s articles on ESSEC Knowledge
- Join Viviane de Beaufort on LinkedIn
The Council on Business & Society Global Alliance is an international alliance between four of the world’s leading business schools and an organiser of Forums focusing on issues at the crossroads of business and society – The Council Community helps bring together business leaders, academics, policy-makers, students and journalists from around the world. Follow us on Twitter #The_CoBS